Online Ordering
You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.
Menu
Our Signature Cakes
From timeless classics to playful creations, every Tracey's Tasties cake is handcrafted using premium ingredients and baked fresh to order. Every cake tells a story—and ours start with quality ingredients, scratch-made recipes, and a whole lot of love. ✨ Made from scratch. Baked with love. Unforgettable in every bite.
Biscoff Me Baby
Moist Biscoff-spiced cake topped with silky caramel, crunchy Biscoff cookie crumbles, and the iconic cookies themselves. Sweet, buttery, and completely irresistible. If you love cookie butter, this one's calling your name!
$50.00

That's How the Cookie Crumbles
Moist buttery cake topped with luscious vanilla buttercream and a mountain of mini chocolate chip cookies—because there's no such thing as too many cookies.
$50.00

Caramel Kisses & Apple Wishes
Moist apple cake layered with warm spices and drizzled with buttery caramel. A cozy, comforting classic in every bite.
$50.00

Turtle-licious
Decadent chocolate cake topped with caramel drizzle and a silky chocolate glaze—rich, gooey, and oh-so indulgent (nuts optional)
$50.00

Proof is in the Pudding
Banana pudding turned into cake! Soft banana cake with creamy pudding goodness that melts in your mouth.
$50.00

Awwww Cookie Cookie Now
Cookies & cream cake with velvety frosting, topped with a chocolate glaze and Oreo crunch. Cookie lovers, rejoice!
$50.00

The Velvet Rope
Decadent red velvet cake with a rich, velvety crumb and a touch of cocoa elegance.
$50.00

Prime Time Lime
Tangy key lime cake bursting with zesty citrus flavor—a refreshing, tropical pick-me-up.
$50.00

Just Peachy
Upside-down peach cobbler cake, golden and gooey with caramelized peaches baked right on top.
$50.00

Pucker Up
Bold, tangy lemon cake that’s zesty, bright, and guaranteed to make your taste buds smile.
$50.00

Lem-Berry Delight
Luscious lemon cake dotted with juicy blueberries—a refreshing, fruity combo.
$50.00

Under My Spell Caramel
Old-fashioned caramel cake, rich and smooth with layers of buttery caramel goodness.
$50.00

Just Marble-ous
Swirls of vanilla and chocolate cake baked together into one stunning, marbled masterpiece.
$50.00

Topsy Turvy
A tropical twist on pineapple upside-down cake, infused with pina colada flavors for a getaway in every bite.
$50.00

Rummmmm and Get It
Moist rum cake made with Malibu or Bacardi—rich, boozy, and dangerously delicious.
$60.00

A Little Taste of Cin
Cinnabon-inspired cake swirled with cinnamon and topped with sweet icing for that fresh-from-the-bakery taste.
$50.00

Gimme S'more
Layers of chocolate and graham-inspired cake topped with marshmallow fluff and chocolate drizzle. A campfire favorite reimagined!
$50.00

Snickerdoodle-Doo
Cinnamon-sugar cake baked to perfection, capturing the flavor of everyone’s favorite cookie in soft, sweet layers.
$50.00

U Down Wit SPP
Sweet potato pound cake, baked with warm spices and your choice of crunchy nuts or without (Seasonal)
$50.00

What's Up Doc
Classic carrot cake loaded with warm spices, fresh carrots, and a hint of sweetness—comfort in every slice.
$50.00

Yes Pe-Can
Buttery pecan cake that’s nutty, rich, and oh-so-satisfying. A Southern favorite with a melt-in-your-mouth finish.
$50.00

"WTF" What The Fudge
Choose chocolate or yellow cake, smothered with rich chocolate frosting. Fudgy, bold, and unforgettable.
$50.00

Create Your Own
Customize your own flavor here
$50.00

Strawberry Fields Collection
Strawberries and Cream
Lush strawberry cake infused with sweet cream—light, fruity, and absolutely indulgent.
$50.00

Strawberry Shortcake
Moist butter cake infused with fresh strawberry purée, layered with cream for a dreamy classic treat.
$50.00

Strawberry Lemonade
Bright lemon cake infused with strawberry purée, perfectly sweet, tart, and refreshing.
$50.00

Strawberry Moscato
Strawberry cake infused with pink Moscato—delicate, sweet, and a little bit bubbly.
$60.00
